Engagementworks
Phone: +64 22 198 5043
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Our Services
    • Audit & Review Services
    • Community engagement checklist
    • Significance & Engagement Resource Kit
    • Resources and Links
  • Buy Community Engagement Basics Online
  • Community Engagement Basics Online
    • Introduction
    • Session 1
    • Session 2
    • Session 3
    • Session 4
    • Session 5
    • Session 6
    • Session 7
    • Session 8
    • Session 9
    • Bonuses
  • Our Training >
    • Short Courses >
      • Governance & leadership (LS-010)
      • Engagement overview (LS-020)
      • Social media for leaders (LS-030)
      • Preparing an engagement strategy (PS-010)
      • Preparing an engagement plan (PS-020)
      • How to use the engagement toolbox (PS-030)
      • How to use engagement planning templates (PS-040)
      • Understanding & planning internal engagement (PS-050)
      • Understanding & using online engagement tools & social media (PS-060)
      • Engagement tips & tricks (PS-070)
      • Engagement case studies (PS-080)
      • Dealing with engagement conflict (PS-090)
    • Practitioner Workshop Series >
      • Community Engagement 101
      • Community Engagement Basics (Local Government)
    • Governance Workshop
    • Training Photo Gallery
  • Our Free Stuff
  • Our Blog
  • Case Studies >
    • Invercargill City's Caravan
    • Sport Bay of Plenty's GO4it Programme
    • Wellington region local government reform
    • Newcastle's fig trees
    • Sport Waitakere's 8M8s
  • Our Newsletters
  • Contact Us

Around and around and around we go

23/7/2015

0 Comments

 
Picture
The Basin Reserve Flyover is back in the news. A flyover was put forward by the New Zealand Transport Agency (NZTA) as a solution to a traffic congestion problem on State Highway 1 near the centre of Wellington. After lengthy and fractious legal issues, the court ruled in favour of the objecting parties who then assumed that by winning their day in court this proposal would be abandoned. Little did they know…

This prolonged and expensive tale of divisive woe is a good case study for how not to go about engaging with a community that will be significantly impacted by a major capital works project.

The first step in any good practice community engagement process should be to identify and prioritise problems that need to be fixed. By drawing on the knowledge, experience and skill of the public to identify and quantify the problem to be solved, and then overlaying technical elements, the NZTA could have produced a sustainable and workable solution acceptable to the majority of the affected communities. This solution could be significantly different from the flyover proposal currently on the table but would have required a completely different approach to that being followed by the NZTA.

The NZTA appears to have identified some technical solutions to a traffic congestion issue around the Basin Reserve and then dumped these on the affected communities with little context provided. Clearly the NZTA is seeing a problem that community groups cannot. This makes it quite difficult for them to sell their “solution”.

The single-mindedness of the NZTA in pursuing its preferred solution through legal channels shows just how little it values the input of communities in good decision-making. These communities not only have very real concerns about the impact of this purely technical solution on the long-term future of the iconic Basin Reserve and the surrounding area but will also be meeting a large part of the project’s costs through their taxes.

Rather than relying on a judicial decision to get its own way, the NZTA would be better served by restarting an engagement process, beginning with listening and responding to community views about the problem to be solved as well as the social and cultural, and economic values those communities attach to the Basin Reserve and its surrounding areas. Restarting this process could save some costs and time and also do much to rebuild the NZTA’s now badly tarnished reputation.
0 Comments
    Picture

    Authors

    Brett & Don share their thoughts. Engagement isn't always the only thing that excites them!

    Archives

    December 2015
    November 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    May 2015
    March 2015
    January 2015
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    April 2014
    February 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013

    Categories

    All
    Advice
    Ideas
    Opinion
    Tools

    RSS Feed

Picture
Engagementworks
© 2023